Perrin case overturned

Perrin case overturned

posted by Chris Hastie on Dec 20 2007 13:20

Perrin & Anor v. Northampton Borough Council was concerned with whether a protected tree on neighbouring land causing subsidence damage to a house could be felled despite its protection by a Tree Preservation Order (TPO). Section 198(6)(b) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 states that a TPO shall not apply to prevent "the cutting down, uprooting, topping or lopping of any trees …so far as may be necessary for the prevention or abatement of a nuisance".

The original judgement in Perrin & Anor v. Northampton Borough Council, passed down in September 2006, held that in determining what work was necessary to prevent or abate a nuisance account could not be taken of any means of preventing the problem which was not tree work. Specifically, the possibility of carrying out engineering works to the house to prevent further damage could not be used to argue that felling was unnecessary.

For those reasons I would hold that the judge's reasoning in paragraph [53] of his judgment is flawed

Appeal judgement

In an appeal decision handed down on 19 December 2007, the Court of Appeal have said that the original judgement was in error. In deciding what is necessary to abate a nuisance all the circumstances of a case must be taken in to account. This may include consideration of engineering works.

The appeal decision closes what many had seen as a very significant loophole in tree protection legislation, potentially allowing insurers to require the removal of many fine trees because this is a cheaper option to them than repairing the building.

The full appeal judgement is avaliable from http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2007/1353.html

The soapbox

The case for a Tree Commission
Posted by John Flannigan
May 07 2007
Trees and climate change
Posted by Chris Hastie
May 02 2007
Subscribe to this blog
Error: Error: A feed could not be found at http://www.tree-care.info/toptreesites/feed.php?1. A feed with an invalid mime type may fall victim to this error, or SimplePie was unable to auto-discover it.. Use force_feed() if you are certain this URL is a real feed.

Latest on UK Tree Care

Posted by Brynley Andrews
Aug 17 2019
Posted by Tom Thompson
Aug 16 2019
Posted by David Evans
Aug 16 2019