Early Forest Supported by the Arborcentre

UKTC Archive

Top 21 Gardening Sites
tree-care.info for tree advice

Re: FORGOTTEN RPA SHAPES

Subject: Re: FORGOTTEN RPA SHAPES
From: Andersonarb
Date: Feb 27 2008 18:44:04
 
In a message dated 26/02/2008 21:06:33 GMT Standard Time,  
luketreescapes@xxxxxxxxxxx.com writes:

If you  don't think that the proposals can be implemented without harming 
important  trees tell the client and if they continue then on their head be  
it.



Isn't that what we do? I've done plenty of jobs where I've told the  
developer to forget it. Well they're like jobs but you seldom seem to get a 
fee  out 
of it....
 
I feel there's a difference between the sites round the country, by the  
sound of things plenty of sites elsewhere just sound like non-starters by my  
local standards. I'd've thought Simon in Bradford was pretty similar to  
Sheffield 
but maybe I'm wrong. I'm sure yours in the Lake District are very  differnt 
Luke, and London? Cheeses only knows.
 
I will say I seem to fairly regularly find myself in dispute with LA bods  
who insist that rubbish trees are choice specimens and as I can't believe any 
 
experienced Arb would make this judgement I'm forced to presume that their 
arms 
 are being twisted. As I point out to clients fairly frequently, there's no 
point  in me telling a client a tree's rubbish when it its a nice specimen, 
he'll only  end up drawing plans based on the tree going and then having to 
redesign. I'll  end up not getting paid or worse, getting sued.
 
This stuff about the TCP not showing circles puzzles me; the TCP is to  
inform the layout, it can't be any other shape until the layout is drawn....  
After 
you've got a layout you can show RPAs a different shape. I do believe  that 
some Planners are failing to understand the RPA's flexibility: I wrote a  
summary of how it should work for a Planner the other week, I thought it was  
perfectly lucid and clear. My girlfriend read it and said "good grief that's 
a  bit 
convoluted." It became apparent that the Planner was still puzzled by  it.
 
Ho hum.
 
Bill.



   

______________________________________________________________________
South Oxfordshire District Council is looking for a Tree Officer on Grade
6, GBP 28,506 - GBP 32,569 per annum (as from 1 April 2008), plus essential 
user
car allowance.  To find out more or apply online, log on to
www.southoxon.gov.uk/jobs where you can look at and download all the job
details and our application form (we don't accept cvs). Alternatively
please call Caron Bourton on 01491 823424 for a job pack.
______________________________________________________________________
-- 
The UK Tree Care mailing list
To unsubscribe send mailto:uktc-unsubscribe@xxxxxx.tree-care.info


Current thread