UKTC Archive

Councils Carrying Out Tree Inspections on Private Land

Subject: Councils Carrying Out Tree Inspections on Private Land
From: Michael Lawson
Date: Dec 21 2011 14:46:34
"There is no fundamental reason why the public sector cannot work just as 
efficiently as the private sector."

Actually Chris there are multiple reasons why the public sector cannot work 
as efficiently as the private sector. But what we must do is appreciate that 
efficiency is a measure of many things. The risk in the debate is to suggest 
that a public sector technical operative cannot be as efficient as a private 
sector operative (wrong) rather than that the drags on his efficiency are 
greater. Drag and efficiency brings to mind motion and efficiency and a Local 
Administrative Authority has all of the aerodynamics of a dead hippopotamus. 
Again at the risk of having the technical tree officers dislike me (which I 
have heard can happen), I am not saying tree officer a,b or c is inefficient, 
in fact in its social service role it is hugely efficient at delivering 
pretty standardised statutory products regardless of changing political 
directives and central government meddling.

However it is pretty universally accepted the big organisations can suffer 
from all of the following (this stuff is all over the web for those 
§  Complexity - the extent to which the business goals are unclear and the 
level of ambiguity in the organisation; if you start offering mixed services 
this will increase
§  Political resistance - the presence of competing interest groups with high 
levels of power and influence; you are democratically driven and not 
commercially driven
§  Cultural resistance - how much a proposed change runs counter to the 
shared assumptions which prevail in the organisation; this is a major drag
§  Size and Scope - the extent to which the change affects lots of people and 
crosses organisational and national boundaries; this certainly applies
§  Lack of change experience - the extent to which managers have led similar 
change programmes in the past, you lack experience in these commercial 
disciplines, honestly you do
All of the purchasing power and inter-departmental resources you reference is 
actually just drag, it's very useful drag to a democratically driven 
statutory delivery vehicle, but its still all cost and drag.

As example you are, in the public sector with pensions about a quarter more 
expensive than an equivalent private sector resource and if we freeze 
everything (unlikely) it would take to around 2020 for the private sector to 
catch up with you.

But actually that's not my big point, I want a public sector, I want it 
delivering consistently on our statutory obligations a common platform set of 
services. In the private sector we have a quality failsafe which always kicks 
in when service levels fall, customers leave and find another supplier, you 
are in a uniquely funded monopolistic position and should not compete with 
your tax base.

As you say:

"Hit a blip and you have much more capacity to re-jig things, temporarily cut 
back on the private work you're taking on, and keep going."

Not really a service ethos my clients let me get away with.

Genuinely - why not write a piece for the AA on "Private Practice the Public 
Sector Way" and I'll do the response.

I have a feeling that as with the Euro the market is going to decide.

Michael Lawson
Managing Director

Landscape Planning Group Ltd
Arboriculture . Ecology . Landscape . Forestry

4 The Courtyards
Phoenix Square
Severalls Park

T: 01206 XXXXXX
F: 01206 XXXXXX
M: 07786 XXXXXX

Skype: Michael.Lawson23<>
[cid:790E1D02-A6B1-4E59-9DF3-1BDBF2768992@home] Follow us on Twitter:

The information in this email and any attachments are confidential and 
intended solely for the use of the addressee. If you are not an addressee, 
any disclosure or copying of the contents of this email or any action taken 
(or not taken) in reliance on it is unauthorised and maybe unlawful.  If you 
are not the addressee, please inform the sender immediately. This email 
represents the personal views of the author / sender and Landscape Planning 
(Group) Ltd and its group companies accepts no responsibility whatsoever for 
its content.
This email message has been delivered safely and archived online by Mimecast.
For more information please visit 

The UK Tree Care mailing list
To unsubscribe send

The UKTC is supported by The Arbor Centre

PNG image